HTML video player comparison: Fluid Player vs. Shaka Player

On this page 4 sections
Shaka Player is the open source video player started by Google. It is a favorite of streaming services: it handles complex streams, protected content and offline viewing, and new versions come out almost every week. Like Fluid Player, it is free. So which one is right for your site?
In this new edition of our comparison series, after Video.js, JW Player, Flowplayer and MediaElement.js, we compare it with Fluid Player, the free and open source HTML5 video player built for publishers. We have compared the latest versions of both players: Fluid Player 3.61 and Shaka Player 5.3.
Feature comparison
| Feature | Fluid Player | Shaka Player |
|---|---|---|
| Price and license | ||
| Free to use | Yes | Yes |
| Open source | Yes | Yes |
| Video ads | ||
| VAST video ads | Yes | Yes |
| Pre-roll, mid-roll and post-roll | Yes | Yes |
| In-video banners | Yes | Yes |
| VPAID ads | Yes | Partly |
| VAST wrappers and fallback ad tags | Yes | Partly |
| Your own HTML banner on pause | Yes | No |
| Server-side ads | No | Yes |
| Streaming and playback | ||
| HLS and DASH streaming | Yes | Yes |
| Live streaming | Yes | Yes |
| VR and 360° video | Yes | Yes |
| Subtitles and captions | Yes | Yes |
| Suggested videos at the end | Yes | No |
| Player features | ||
| Timeline thumbnail previews | Yes | Yes |
| Mini player or floating player | Yes | Partly |
| Keyboard shortcuts | Yes | Yes |
| Remembers viewer settings | Yes | No |
| Interface translations | Partly | Yes |
| Casting (AirPlay, Chromecast) | No | Yes |
| Setup and support | ||
| npm package | Yes | Yes |
| Visual player builder | Yes | No |
| Official WordPress plugin | Yes | No |
| Free support from the team | Yes | Yes |
Shaka Player’s amber marks need a word of explanation. Shaka now reads simple VAST and VMAP ads by itself, but for VPAID ads and VAST wrappers it relies on Google’s IMA SDK, a separate script that you add and set up next to the player. For a smaller player, Shaka offers picture-in-picture, but not a mini player that stays on the page.
Both players are free and open source, so this comparison is not about price. It is about who each player is built for. Shaka Player is a powerful streaming engine for development teams, with DRM, offline playback and server-side ads. Fluid Player is built for publishers: the ad formats publishers use every day work out of the box, with no extra script, and features such as suggested videos, a mini player and remembered viewer settings are ready to switch on.
Fluid Player: open source, ready to use and ready for video ads
Fluid Player is a lightweight HTML5 video player built for publishers who want to show and monetize video. It is free and open source under the MIT license, with its code public on GitHub (opens in a new tab), and new versions come out regularly. Load it from our own CDN, install it with npm or host the files yourself.
Ready to use, easy to make your own
Fluid Player looks good with its default settings, and everything it can do is in a single script, so you can start publishing videos with a few lines of code:
<script src="https://cdn.fluidplayer.com/v3/current/fluidplayer.min.js"></script>
<video id="my-video">
<source src="my-video.mp4" type="video/mp4">
</video>
<script>
fluidPlayer('my-video');
</script>To match your brand, simple settings let you change the color of the controls, add your logo and a poster image, choose which buttons to show, add timeline thumbnail previews, enable theater mode or the mini player, customize the keyboard shortcuts and much more. You don’t need to be a developer: the Player Builder on our homepage lets you try every setting on a live player, then copy the code.
Video ads with any ad network, no extra script
Fluid Player supports VAST, the Interactive Advertising Bureau (IAB) (opens in a new tab) standard that ad servers use to deliver video ads, out of the box. Everything is built into the player, with no third-party ad script to add. It works with any ad network, ad exchange or video ad server, and you keep all of your ad revenue:
- several ads per video: pre-roll, mid-roll and post-roll;
- linear (video) ads, with a skip button and a call to action;
- non-linear ads: image banners (GIF, JPEG or PNG) shown over the video;
- your own HTML banner when the viewer pauses the video;
- VAST wrappers, ad pods and fallback ad tags;
- VPAID 2.0 ads, switched on with one option.
Adding an ad takes one setting:
fluidPlayer('my-video', {
vastOptions: {
adList: [
{ roll: 'preRoll', vastTag: 'https://example.com/your-vast-tag.xml' }
]
}
});Open source: you stay in control
Fluid Player’s code is public on GitHub (opens in a new tab) under the MIT license, one of the most permissive open source licenses. In practice, this means:
- No lock-in: there is no license key, subscription or contract. The player is yours to use on as many sites as you like, for as long as you like.
- Full transparency: anyone can read the code and check exactly what the player does on your pages.
- Freedom to adapt: if you need something special, you can change the player or build on top of it.
- Free updates, always: every new version is free.
Streaming, subtitles and VR
Fluid Player plays MP4 and WebM files and HLS and DASH streams, including live streams. Subtitles use WebVTT, the most widely used caption format on the web. Fluid Player also plays 360° videos, with a Cardboard view for VR headsets. At the end of a video, you can show suggested videos to keep viewers watching, and the player remembers each viewer’s volume, speed and quality for their next visit.
Documentation and support
Every option is explained in the Fluid Player documentation (opens in a new tab), with guides for React, Vue, Angular and WordPress (opens in a new tab). Have a question or found a problem? Open an issue on GitHub (opens in a new tab): the Fluid Player team reads and answers them, for free, and fixes land in regular releases.
Shaka Player: a streaming engine for developers
Shaka Player (opens in a new tab) was started by Google and is now developed in the open by the Shaka Project, under the Apache 2.0 license. It is first of all a JavaScript library for adaptive streaming, with an optional set of ready-made controls on top.
What Shaka Player does well
- Professional streaming: HLS and DASH, low-latency live streaming and many formats, with very frequent releases.
- Protected content: DRM with Widevine, PlayReady and FairPlay, the systems used by the big streaming services.
- Offline playback: videos can be downloaded and watched later without a connection.
- Advanced advertising: server-side ads with Google’s IMA SDK or AWS MediaTailor, plus HLS and DASH interstitials.
- More playback features: casting to Chromecast and AirPlay, chapters, playlists and an interface translated into more than 40 languages.
- Active support: questions and bug reports on GitHub get answers from the team.
What to keep in mind
- Made for developers: Shaka is a library first. Most options, ads included, are set in JavaScript, and its documentation is written for developers.
- Ads often need Google’s IMA SDK: Shaka’s own VAST support covers simple ads only. For VAST wrappers and VPAID ads, you add Google’s IMA SDK and set it up in code.
- No visual builder or WordPress plugin: there is no tool to set up the player without code, and no official WordPress plugin.
- Fewer ready-made features for publishers: there are no suggested videos at the end, no mini player beyond picture-in-picture, and viewer settings such as volume aren’t remembered.
Conclusion: which player should you choose?
Choose Fluid Player if you want to publish and monetize video with a player that works in a few lines of code. VAST and VPAID ads, wrappers, banners, streaming, VR, suggested videos and the mini player are all built in, it is free and open source, and our team answers your questions on GitHub.
Choose Shaka Player if you have a development team building a streaming service that needs DRM, offline playback or server-side ads.
Both players are free and open source, but only one is built around publishers. For sites that want to earn revenue from their videos from day one, Fluid Player is the smart choice. Try it in the Player Builder and see your player take shape in a few clicks.


