YouTube embed or your own video player? Fluid Player vs. YouTube

On this page 10 sections

Every publisher with videos faces the same question sooner or later: should I upload my videos to YouTube and embed them on my site, or host them myself and play them in my own player? YouTube looks like the obvious answer. It’s free, it’s easy, and everyone knows it. But “free” has a price: someone else chooses the ads, takes a share of the revenue, and decides what your viewers see next.

In this edition of our comparison series, we look at both options side by side: an embedded YouTube video, and your own videos played in Fluid Player, the free and open source HTML5 video player built for publishers. This isn’t a comparison of two players with the same goal. YouTube is a video platform; Fluid Player is a player for your own site. The right choice depends on what you want from your videos, and we will be honest about where YouTube wins.

Feature comparison

Comparison of playing your videos in Fluid Player or in an embedded YouTube player
FeatureFluid PlayerYouTube embed
Revenue
Choose your own ad network Yes No
Keep all of your ad revenue Yes No
Earn from your very first video Yes No
Only the ads you choose Yes No
Your viewers and your brand
Viewers stay on your site Yes Partly
Only the suggested videos you choose Yes Partly
Your logo, no third-party branding Yes No
Full control over the player's look Yes No
You set the content rules Yes No
Your site
Search traffic goes to your page Yes Partly
Lightweight player Yes No
No third-party tracking Yes Partly
Hosting and audience
Free video storage and bandwidth No Yes
Automatic encoding in every quality No Yes
A built-in audience to be discovered by No Yes

In this table, a green mark means the option is better for you as a publisher. A few marks need a word of explanation. YouTube lets viewers click through to youtube.com from the player, so they don’t always stay on your page. Its settings can limit the suggested videos to your own channel, but can’t turn them off. Search traffic to your video can go to your page or to YouTube, as we explain below. And YouTube’s privacy-enhanced mode reduces tracking, but doesn’t remove YouTube from your page.

The short version: YouTube is the easier way to be seen; your own player is the better way to earn. YouTube takes care of hosting and can bring you an audience. Fluid Player gives you the ads, the revenue, the viewers and the search traffic.

Who earns from the ads?

This is the biggest difference, so let’s start here.

With YouTube, ads are sold by Google. You can’t choose your ad network, your ad formats or how often ads play. You only get a share of the revenue once you join the YouTube Partner Program, which today asks for 1,000 subscribers and 4,000 hours of watch time in the last 12 months (or 10 million Shorts views in 90 days), followed by a review of your channel. YouTube has also announced changes to the program from February 2027. Once accepted, you receive 55% of the net ad revenue from your videos, including when they play on your own site.

Until then, you earn nothing, but your videos can still show ads: YouTube’s terms give it the right to monetize all content on its service, and say plainly that this doesn’t entitle you to any payment.

With Fluid Player, the ads are yours from the first video. Fluid Player supports VAST, the Interactive Advertising Bureau (IAB) (opens in a new tab) standard that ad servers use to deliver video ads, so it works with any ad network, ad exchange or video ad server. You choose the ads, where they play and how many, and you keep all of the revenue:

  • several ads per video: pre-roll, mid-roll and post-roll;
  • linear (video) ads, with a skip button and a call to action;
  • non-linear ads: image banners shown over the video;
  • your own HTML banner when the viewer pauses the video;
  • VAST wrappers, ad pods and fallback ad tags;
  • VPAID 2.0 ads, switched on with one option.

Adding an ad takes one setting:

JavaScript
fluidPlayer('my-video', {
  vastOptions: {
    adList: [
      { roll: 'preRoll', vastTag: 'https://example.com/your-vast-tag.xml' }
    ]
  }
});

Who owns the viewer?

An embedded YouTube video is a small piece of YouTube on your page. The YouTube logo and the video title link to youtube.com, so a click takes your viewer away from your site. At the end of the video, YouTube shows suggested videos. You can limit them to your own channel, but you can’t turn them off, and YouTube’s former option to reduce its branding has had no effect since 2023.

With your own player, your page stays your page. Fluid Player shows your logo, your colors and your poster image. At the end of a video, you choose the suggested videos (opens in a new tab), so viewers keep watching your content, on your site, where your ads play.

Who gets the search traffic?

Videos are a great way to be found on search engines. But when your video is on YouTube, search engines often show the youtube.com page in their results, and the visit goes to YouTube instead of your site. When the video is hosted on your own page, the search traffic it earns is yours, along with the text, links and ads around it. To help search engines find your videos, describe them with video structured data or a video sitemap.

Page speed matters for your visitors and for search. A YouTube embed loads YouTube’s own player, which is more than half a megabyte of JavaScript and styles, from Google’s servers, even if the visitor never presses play. Fluid Player is a single, lightweight script that you load from our CDN or from your own server.

There is also privacy to think of. An embedded YouTube player connects your visitors to YouTube. Its privacy-enhanced mode reduces this, but YouTube still loads on your page, and in many countries this means asking visitors for consent first. Fluid Player itself doesn’t track your visitors: the only third parties on your page are the ones you choose, such as your ad network.

Content rules

YouTube decides what is allowed on YouTube. Its Community Guidelines don’t accept some types of content at all, its advertiser guidelines limit which videos can earn money, and a channel can lose its revenue or be removed after warnings, sometimes with little notice. If your business depends on a channel, it depends on someone else’s rules.

With your own player on your own site, you set the rules, within the law and your ad network’s policies. Content YouTube doesn’t accept can still be published and monetized.

What hosting your own videos involves

To be fair to YouTube, this is where it shines. YouTube stores your videos, delivers them worldwide and converts them into every quality for every device, all for free. Fluid Player is a player: it plays your videos, but you need to host them somewhere. In practice, this means:

  • Storage and delivery: your videos live on your server, in cloud storage or with a video hosting service, ideally delivered through a CDN so they load quickly everywhere.
  • Bandwidth costs: every view uses bandwidth, which you pay for. For a site that earns from its videos, the ad revenue you keep usually covers this.
  • Encoding: for the best experience, prepare each video in several qualities, for example as an HLS or DASH stream. Fluid Player then picks the right quality for each viewer automatically. A simple MP4 file works too.

Many video hosting services take care of storage, encoding and delivery for you and give you a link to play in your own player, so you get YouTube’s convenience without giving up your ads and your viewers.

The best of both

You don’t have to choose only one. Many publishers use YouTube to be discovered, with trailers, clips and highlights that point to their site, and their own site to earn, with the full videos played in their own player and their own ads. YouTube brings the audience; your site keeps it.

Fluid Player: your videos, your player, your revenue

Fluid Player is a lightweight HTML5 video player built for publishers who want to show and monetize video. It is free and open source under the MIT license, with its code public on GitHub (opens in a new tab). There is no account, license key or contract, and no one takes a share of your revenue. It plays MP4 and WebM files, HLS and DASH streams including live streams, WebVTT subtitles and 360° videos.

Getting started takes a few lines of code:

HTML
<script src="https://cdn.fluidplayer.com/v3/current/fluidplayer.min.js"></script>

<video id="my-video">
  <source src="my-video.mp4" type="video/mp4">
</video>

<script>
  fluidPlayer('my-video');
</script>

To match your brand, simple settings let you change the color of the controls, add your logo and a poster image, choose which buttons to show, add timeline thumbnail previews, enable theater mode or the mini player and much more. You don’t need to be a developer: the Player Builder on our homepage lets you try every setting on a live player, then copy the code. Every option is explained in the Fluid Player documentation (opens in a new tab), with guides for React, Vue, Angular and WordPress (opens in a new tab), and our team answers your questions on GitHub (opens in a new tab), for free.

Conclusion: YouTube or your own player?

Choose YouTube if your main goal is reach: you want to be discovered on the world’s biggest video platform, you don’t want to deal with hosting, and earning from ads on your own site isn’t a priority.

Choose your own player with Fluid Player if your site is your business. You choose the ads and keep all of the revenue from the first view, your viewers stay on your site, the search traffic comes to you, and you set the rules for your content.

And if you want both, use YouTube to be found and your site to earn. Try Fluid Player in the Player Builder and see your player take shape in a few clicks.